50
Ann Hersey Allison
thought to be the villanello in the 1496 inventory, but by this date the motif of Meleager killing the boar on antique
sarcophagi was undoubtedly recognized. Mantuan humanists also were more than likely aware of the closely
similar description of Meleager by Philostratus the Younger (“Imagines”, 15). This identification, together with
the style of the Statuette, make a date c. 1500 more likely. Again, the pose is strong, here energized by drapery,
and the face is expressive. On a technical basis the Castings of the Jantzen “Young Hercules” (cat. 17, A) and the
Florence “Cupid” (cat. 15, A) appear to have been executed either together or very close to each other. Both needed
considerable repair to the legs after Casting and this work is identical in technique. The “Cupid” is probably a
replica of a figure in the 1496 inventory, as is the “Young Hercules”.
The statuettes that can be dated in the later part of the decade have smaller heads, proportionately longer legs,
more graceful poses, and include Antico’s most complicated motif, the Atropos. As indicated above, the motif of
Hercules and Antaeus (cat. 18) is to be dated before the Bishop Lodovico’s death in 1511. The terminus post quem
for this motif is established by the position of Antaeus’ head which was derived from that of “Laocoon” in the
antique group discovered in January of 1506. The main prototype for Antico’s Hercules and Antaeus was, as
pointed out by Hermann 90 , the now restored group in the courtyard of the Palazzo Pitti in Florence, available to
the sculptor c. 1500 91 . The group was not restored in Antico’s lifetime. Hercules lacked his left lower leg, the right
leg from mid-thigh, the two lower arms, and left shoulder blade. Antaeus was in worse condition, missing his head
and neck, his left shoulder blade, lower arm and leg, his right arm, a portion of the body beneath it, and the right
leg from mid-thigh 92 . From this fragment Antico has created an integrated, if unstable motif which has been refined
and given expressive contrast. He has restored and fitted the group into the abstract format of a triangle. In the
leftward sagging position of Antaeus’ head he added his usual central accent, whereas that of the antique torso
clearly came forward. Additionally, the bodies were slightly elongated and stiffened, and Antaeus portrayed near
demise by the collapse of his abdomen, this last reflecting that of Antaeus in Mantegna’s group in the Camera degli
Sposi. Influences of Philostratus the Elder’s description of this subject upon both artists could be the expression
of Antaeus, for Mantegna’s earlier design the back to front composition, and for Antico the depiction of veins in
stress 93 . In their compositions the antitheses of bodily expression is paralleled by contrasts in facial expression.
Antico’s group is facially more restrained, but he formally intensified the contrapposti through the sinking head
of Antaeus and his powerless arm which is held imprisoned by Hercules. The Renaissance concept of this struggle
as the victory of virtue over vice is thus admirably portrayed by both artists. The Vienna “Hercules and Antaeus”
with Isabella’s inscription (cat. 18, B) for which Antico provided only the wax model c. 1519 is stylistically later
than a fully autograph bronze of this group in London (cat. 18, A). It is significant to note the differing facial
expressions of Antaeus, that in London portraying heroic suffering in the classical manner, while that of Isabella’s
bronze is pathetic. The London bronze probably belonged to the Bishop, its heroism confirming this dating in
its reflection of the spirit of Mantegna and the confident humanism of the early sixteenth Century.
90 ) Hermann, op. cit. (cf. n. 1), pp. 264 f.
The group now in the Palazzo Pitti was documented as in the Vatican Belvedere in 1509 (cf. F. Albertini, op. cit., cf. n. 83, fol. 60 v.).
Albertini considered the Pitti group to be a work by Polykleitos. The provenance of the ancient torsos is unknown. A. Mezzetti (Un’Ercole
e Anteo del Mantegna, in: Bolletino d’Arte, 1958, pp. 232 f) saw their influence upon the engravings of the Mantegna school and, along with
W. Stedman-Sheard (Antiquity in the Renaissance, Northampton, 1978, no. 94) and A. Radcliffe (The Victoria and Albert Museum,
Splendours of the Gonzaga, London, 1981, no. 55), upon the “Hercules and Antaeus” in the Camera degli Sposi completed in 1474. H. Möbius
(Vier Hellenistische Skulpturen, in: Antike Plastik, X, 3, 1970, p. 39) did not perceive an influence of the Pitti group upon these works. On
the basis of the Bramante-attributed drawing at Windsor and a bronze group in the Bargello Möbius rightly concluded that the marble
fragment was known only by c. 1500 (for the Windsor drawing cf. A. E. Popham/J. Wilde, The Italian Drawings of the XV and XVI Centuries
in the Collection of His Majesty the King at Windsor Palace, London, 1949, no. 17, pl. 155; W. Suida, Bramante e il Bramantino, 1953, pl. 29y
Mezzetti, op. cit., cf. above, fig. 23; for the Bargello bronze cf. F. Rossi, II Museo Nazionale di Firenze, 1951 and Mezzetti, op. cit., cf. above,
p. 243, fig. 22, who dated the latter in the fifteenth Century; H. R. Weihrauch, Europäische Bronzestatuetten, Braunschweig, 1967, p. 122,
fig. 136, who placed it c. 1500; L. Planiscig, Kunsthistorisches Museum, Die Bronzeplastiken, Vienna, 1924, no. 110, who dated a duplicate
in Vienna in the first half of the sixteenth Century.
92 ) H. Dütschke, Antike Bildwerke in Oberitalien, Leipzig, 1874-1882, II, 18, no. 37.
93) Philostratus The Elder, Imagines, II, 21. Mantegna’s fresco does not convincingly reflect a knowledge of the antique torsos (cf. note
above). His motif appears to be the earliest instance of the use of Philostratus as an artistic source. A translation of Philostratus was owned
by Isabella d’Este (A. Luzio/R. Renier, La Coltura e Le Relazione Lettrarie di Isabella d’Este, I, La Coltura, in: Giornale Storico della
Letteratura Italiana, XXXIII, 1899, p. 22, n. 4). Noting the positions of Antaeus’ legs and the tiptoe position of one of Hercules’ feet, Mantegna,
in reverse, and Antico may have had the additional authority of a widely circulated coin minted in Alexandria under Antoninus Pius (BMC,
Alexandria, 1892, no. 1054, pl. VI). K. Clark (The Nude, New York, 1959, p. 196) pointed to the possibility of this source. A coin of Geta
has an almost identical motif (BMC, no. 1479, pl. VI). Mantegna’s fresco is indistinct in the lower portion, but, judging from the adjacent deed
of Hercules, Hercules’ left foot was most likely on tiptoe.