Full text : Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien, Band 53/54 (N.F.) (LIII/LIV=89/90)

50

Ann  Hersey  Allison

thought  to  be  the  villanello  in  the  1496  inventory,  but  by  this  date  the  motif  of  Meleager  killing  the  boar  on  antique
sarcophagi  was  undoubtedly  recognized.  Mantuan  humanists  also  were  more  than  likely  aware  of  the  closely
similar  description  of  Meleager  by  Philostratus  the  Younger  (“Imagines”,  15).  This  identification,  together  with
the  style  of  the  Statuette,  make  a  date  c.  1500  more  likely.  Again,  the  pose  is  strong,  here  energized  by  drapery,
and  the  face  is  expressive.  On  a  technical  basis  the  Castings  of  the  Jantzen  “Young  Hercules”  (cat.  17,  A)  and  the
Florence  “Cupid”  (cat.  15,  A)  appear  to  have  been  executed  either  together  or  very  close  to  each  other.  Both  needed
considerable  repair  to  the  legs  after  Casting  and  this  work  is  identical  in  technique.  The  “Cupid”  is  probably  a
replica  of  a  figure  in  the  1496  inventory,  as  is  the  “Young  Hercules”.
The  statuettes  that  can  be  dated  in  the  later  part  of  the  decade  have  smaller  heads,  proportionately  longer  legs,
more  graceful  poses,  and  include  Antico’s  most  complicated  motif,  the  Atropos.  As  indicated  above,  the  motif  of
Hercules  and  Antaeus  (cat.  18)  is  to  be  dated  before  the  Bishop  Lodovico’s  death  in  1511.  The  terminus  post  quem
for  this  motif  is  established  by  the  position  of  Antaeus’  head  which  was  derived  from  that  of  “Laocoon”  in  the
antique  group  discovered  in  January  of  1506.  The  main  prototype  for  Antico’s  Hercules  and  Antaeus  was,  as
pointed  out  by  Hermann 90 ,  the  now  restored  group  in  the  courtyard  of  the  Palazzo  Pitti  in  Florence,  available  to
the  sculptor  c.  1500 91 .  The  group  was  not  restored  in  Antico’s  lifetime.  Hercules  lacked  his  left  lower  leg,  the  right
leg  from  mid-thigh,  the  two  lower  arms,  and  left  shoulder  blade.  Antaeus  was  in  worse  condition,  missing  his  head
and  neck,  his  left  shoulder  blade,  lower  arm  and  leg,  his  right  arm,  a  portion  of  the  body  beneath  it,  and  the  right
leg  from  mid-thigh 92 .  From  this  fragment  Antico  has  created  an  integrated,  if  unstable  motif  which  has  been  refined
and  given  expressive  contrast.  He  has  restored  and  fitted  the  group  into  the  abstract  format  of  a  triangle.  In  the
leftward  sagging  position  of  Antaeus’  head  he  added  his  usual  central  accent,  whereas  that  of  the  antique  torso
clearly  came  forward.  Additionally,  the  bodies  were  slightly  elongated  and  stiffened,  and  Antaeus  portrayed  near
demise  by  the  collapse  of  his  abdomen,  this  last  reflecting  that  of  Antaeus  in  Mantegna’s  group  in  the  Camera  degli
Sposi.  Influences  of  Philostratus  the  Elder’s  description  of  this  subject  upon  both  artists  could  be  the  expression
of  Antaeus,  for  Mantegna’s  earlier  design  the  back  to  front  composition,  and  for  Antico  the  depiction  of  veins  in
stress 93 .  In  their  compositions  the  antitheses  of  bodily  expression  is  paralleled  by  contrasts  in  facial  expression.
Antico’s  group  is  facially  more  restrained,  but  he  formally  intensified  the  contrapposti  through  the  sinking  head
of  Antaeus  and  his  powerless  arm  which  is  held  imprisoned  by  Hercules.  The  Renaissance  concept  of  this  struggle
as  the  victory  of  virtue  over  vice  is  thus  admirably  portrayed  by  both  artists.  The  Vienna  “Hercules  and  Antaeus”
with  Isabella’s  inscription  (cat.  18,  B)  for  which  Antico  provided  only  the  wax  model  c.  1519  is  stylistically  later
than  a  fully  autograph  bronze  of  this  group  in  London  (cat.  18,  A).  It  is  significant  to  note  the  differing  facial
expressions  of  Antaeus,  that  in  London  portraying  heroic  suffering  in  the  classical  manner,  while  that  of  Isabella’s
bronze  is  pathetic.  The  London  bronze  probably  belonged  to  the  Bishop,  its  heroism  confirming  this  dating  in
its  reflection  of  the  spirit  of  Mantegna  and  the  confident  humanism  of  the  early  sixteenth  Century.

90 )  Hermann,  op.  cit.  (cf.  n.  1),  pp.  264  f.
The  group  now  in  the  Palazzo  Pitti  was  documented  as  in  the  Vatican  Belvedere  in  1509  (cf.  F.  Albertini,  op.  cit.,  cf.  n.  83,  fol.  60  v.).
Albertini  considered  the  Pitti  group  to  be  a  work  by  Polykleitos.  The  provenance  of  the  ancient  torsos  is  unknown.  A.  Mezzetti  (Un’Ercole
e  Anteo  del  Mantegna,  in:  Bolletino  d’Arte,  1958,  pp.  232  f)  saw  their  influence  upon  the  engravings  of  the  Mantegna  school  and,  along  with
W.  Stedman-Sheard  (Antiquity  in  the  Renaissance,  Northampton,  1978,  no.  94)  and  A.  Radcliffe  (The  Victoria  and  Albert  Museum,
Splendours  of  the  Gonzaga,  London,  1981,  no.  55),  upon  the  “Hercules  and  Antaeus”  in  the  Camera  degli  Sposi  completed  in  1474.  H.  Möbius
(Vier  Hellenistische  Skulpturen,  in:  Antike  Plastik,  X,  3,  1970,  p.  39)  did  not  perceive  an  influence  of  the  Pitti  group  upon  these  works.  On
the  basis  of  the  Bramante-attributed  drawing  at  Windsor  and  a  bronze  group  in  the  Bargello  Möbius  rightly  concluded  that  the  marble
fragment  was  known  only  by  c.  1500  (for  the  Windsor  drawing  cf.  A.  E.  Popham/J.  Wilde,  The  Italian  Drawings  of  the  XV  and  XVI  Centuries
in  the  Collection  of  His  Majesty  the  King  at  Windsor  Palace,  London,  1949,  no.  17,  pl.  155;  W.  Suida,  Bramante  e  il  Bramantino,  1953,  pl.  29y
Mezzetti,  op.  cit.,  cf.  above,  fig.  23;  for  the  Bargello  bronze  cf.  F.  Rossi,  II  Museo  Nazionale  di  Firenze,  1951  and  Mezzetti,  op.  cit.,  cf.  above,
p.  243,  fig.  22,  who  dated  the  latter  in  the  fifteenth  Century;  H.  R.  Weihrauch,  Europäische  Bronzestatuetten,  Braunschweig,  1967,  p.  122,
fig.  136,  who  placed  it  c.  1500;  L.  Planiscig,  Kunsthistorisches  Museum,  Die  Bronzeplastiken,  Vienna,  1924,  no.  110,  who  dated  a  duplicate
in  Vienna  in  the  first  half  of  the  sixteenth  Century.
92 )  H.  Dütschke,  Antike  Bildwerke  in  Oberitalien,  Leipzig,  1874-1882,  II,  18,  no.  37.
93)  Philostratus  The  Elder,  Imagines,  II,  21.  Mantegna’s  fresco  does  not  convincingly  reflect  a  knowledge  of  the  antique  torsos  (cf.  note
above).  His  motif  appears  to  be  the  earliest  instance  of  the  use  of  Philostratus  as  an  artistic  source.  A  translation  of  Philostratus  was  owned
by  Isabella  d’Este  (A.  Luzio/R.  Renier,  La  Coltura  e  Le  Relazione  Lettrarie  di  Isabella  d’Este,  I,  La  Coltura,  in:  Giornale  Storico  della
Letteratura  Italiana,  XXXIII,  1899,  p.  22,  n.  4).  Noting  the  positions  of  Antaeus’  legs  and  the  tiptoe  position  of  one  of  Hercules’  feet,  Mantegna,
in  reverse,  and  Antico  may  have  had  the  additional  authority  of  a  widely  circulated  coin  minted  in  Alexandria  under  Antoninus  Pius  (BMC,
Alexandria,  1892,  no.  1054,  pl.  VI).  K.  Clark  (The  Nude,  New  York,  1959,  p.  196)  pointed  to  the  possibility  of  this  source.  A  coin  of  Geta
has  an  almost  identical  motif  (BMC,  no.  1479,  pl.  VI).  Mantegna’s  fresco  is  indistinct  in  the  lower  portion,  but,  judging  from  the  adjacent  deed
of  Hercules,  Hercules’  left  foot  was  most  likely  on  tiptoe.
            
Waiting...

Note to user

Dear user,

In response to current developments in the web technology used by the Goobi viewer, the software no longer supports your browser.

Please use one of the following browsers to display this page correctly.

Thank you.